Director General of Posts & Ors. v. B. Ravindran & Anr.
Supreme Court of India, Civil Appeals 14493‑14512 of 1996, decision dated 8 November 1996 (Indian Kanoon)
Background of the Case related to Pay Fixation in Reemployed Post
Supreme Court has delivered an important judgement in favour of the Reemployed Exserviceman which allows pay fixation in central civil service services at higher stage. Lets know the case details.
Item | Detail |
Respondent (original applicant) | B. Ravindran, retired Sergeant, Indian Air Force (service 1965‑1980); re‑employed 29 Nov 1983 as Postal Assistant, DoP. |
Core grievance | His civil pay was fixed at the minimum of the Postal‑Assistant scale (₹260) even though MoF OM 25‑11‑1958—read with subsequent relaxations—permitted advance increments if the re‑employment package fell short of the last pay in uniform. |
Trigger for litigation | Department of Posts circular 30‑12‑1985 (issued after DoPT consultation) said “hardship” had to be tested after adding back even the ignorable portion of pension & gratuity, effectively denying increments. |
CAT outcome | A Full Bench of CAT‑Ernakulam quashed the 1985 clarification and ordered one increment per completed year of equivalent military service (11 years in Ravindran’s case), giving higher‑stage fixation. |
Appeal | Union of India (Director‑General of Posts) filed a batch of civil appeals; all were clubbed and argued together. |
Arguments before the Supreme Court
Appellants (DoP) | Respondents (Ex‑servicemen) |
1958 OM is the foundational policy: advance increments are allowed only when pay + pension + PEG < last pay; adding ignorable pension is therefore proper. | Subsequent OMs (1963, 1964, 1978, 8‑2‑1983) and amendments to CSR Art. 526 explicitly ignore a part or whole of pension before computing hardship; the 1985 letter cannot override those statutory changes. |
1985 circular is merely “clarificatory”, hence can operate retrospectively. | 1985 letter is inconsistent with statutory CSR amendments and seeks to reduce an accrued benefit; it cannot be retrospective. |
Key Findings of the Court
- Statutory force of CSR Art. 526 – After the 1964 amendment, CSR became part of binding service law under Article 313 of the Constitution; executive clarifications cannot whittle it down.
- Policy evolution altered the 1958 baseline – OMs of 1963, 1964, 1978 and MoD 8‑2‑1983 were “relaxations intended to confer additional benefit”; they must be given effect before assessing hardship.
- Ignorable pension must stay ignored – While comparing pay (on re‑employment) + pension with last pay, the portion of pension declared ignorable cannot be added back; otherwise the relaxation becomes illusory.
- 1985 DoP clarification invalid – It directly contradicted both CSR and the 1983 MoD order, and sought to claw back benefits retrospectively; therefore ultra vires.
Operative Order & Relief
- All civil appeals dismissed; CAT orders affirmed.
- Department directed to refix pay of the respondents at a higher stage by granting one increment for each completed year of equivalent military service, provided pay (on re‑employment) + non‑ignorable pension was still below last military pay.
- No costs awarded.
Practical Impact
Aspect | Consequence |
Financial gain | In Ravindran’s scale (Rs 260‑480), 11 increments pushed starting basic to Rs 350, restoring parity with his last IAF pay (Rs 400) after permissible pension adjustments—about 34 % higher than entry pay. |
Precedent value | The judgment became a cornerstone for PBORs fighting post‑1986 discrimination, because it: 1) recognised the right to higher‑stage fixation once a shortfall exists, and 2) treated ignorable pension as truly ignorable. |
Limitations | The ruling predates the CCS (Fixation of Pay of Re‑employed Pensioners) Orders, 1986; later executive instructions (e.g., DoPT OM 11‑11‑2008, 05‑04‑2010) carved out a different two‑track system. Yet, Ravindran remains persuasive where departments resurrect the 1985 logic. |
Why It Is Still Cited (2025)
- Audit disputes: Departments occasionally rely on the 1985 formula; employees cite Ravindran to get those audit objections dropped.
- Bank & PSU practice: PSBs point to Ravindran to defend their long‑standing same‑stage fixation policy for all ranks.
- Policy‑reform campaigns: Veteran bodies invoke the reasoning (ignorable pension + hardship test) while seeking amendments to Rule 4(b)(i) of the 1986 Orders so that PBORs in ministries can enjoy parity with their PSU counterparts.
Take‑away
Ravindran establishes that once the Government itself decides to ignore a part (or whole) of pension for a class of early‑retired soldiers, it cannot re‑insert that pension through a back‑door “clarification” to deny higher‑stage pay fixation. The judgment thus stands as an enduring benchmark for fair, rule‑based rehabilitation of ex‑servicemen after they hang up their uniform.
- CSD Car Purchase Guide (June 2025): Price List & Eligibility for Defence Personnel🔰 Introduction The Canteen Stores Department (CSD) offers serving and
- Wearing of Medals by Ex-Servicemen on Civil Attire — Official GuidelinesLet’s hold the Legacy of Wearing Medals by Exservicemen Medals
- Home Delivery of Medicines for ECHS Beneficiaries: Process & Payment MethodologyThe Process to Facilitate our Veterans To enhance accessibility to
- Distinct Vertical Promotion Quota for Re-Employed Ex-Servicemen in Government Services and PSUsAuthor : Bikash De – Editor, ESM Info Club 🔹
- Uniform Pay Fixation for Reemployed Ex-Servicemen: Time for Legal Action as Government Delays JusticeA Persistent Injustice with PBOR Despite years of dedicated service
- Trade Equivalence for Indian Army, Navy & Air Force Trades: A Gateway to Civilian Employment for Ex-ServicemenAuthor : Bikash De – Editor, ESM Info Club Why
- ECHS Introduces Online Procedure to Correct Wrong Mobile Numbers During RegistrationECHS Mobile Number Change The Central Organisation ECHS (Ex-Servicemen Contributory
- Respect the Armed Forces — You Sleep Peacefully Because of Them: Supreme Court🔹 Supreme Court’s Strong Remarks on Assault Allegations Against Army
- Grant of Ex‑Servicemen (ESM) status to recruits boarded out on medical grounds with disability pensionBackground & Policy Context Office Memorandum: 1 February 2006 “Recruits boarded out/released
- SPARSH: A Game-Changer in Defence Pension AdministrationThe Indian Ministry of Defence has launched an integrated pension
- Major Postal Reform: India Post to Merge Registered Post with Speed Post from 1st September 2025Registered Post is now past and it will no more
- SPARSH Problem solution – Amazing Steps by PCDASBI Designates 699 Branches as SPARSH Service Centres for Defence
- Anomaly in Pay Fixation of Reemployed Ex-Servicemen (JCOs/OR) : Possible Solution The reemployment of ex-servicemen, particularly Junior Commissioned Officers (JCOs) and
- IGI Aviation Recruitment 2025: 1446 Vacancies for Ground Staff & Loader PostsIGI Aviation Services has announced a major recruitment drive for
- Ex-Servicemen to Receive Reservation Every Time: Major Relief by High CourtKey Highlights: Background: The Uttarakhand government had issued an order
- Indian Army Centre Rally Bharti Schedule – August 2025All-India Relation & Sportsmen Rally Recruitment Calendar The Indian Army
- Restoration of Commuted Pension: Government Reiterates Policy Based on Supreme Court JudgementsBackground The Department of Pension & Pensioners’ Welfare has issued
- Step-by-Step Guide to Claim Disability Pension Exemption in Both Old and New Tax Regimes of ITR e FilingMany pensioners often wonder whether disability pension is still exempt
- ECHS Introduces Home Delivery of Medicines for VeteransNew Scheme Approved by MoD (DESW) Dated: 25 July 2025Issued
- Now Two Children of Army Personnel Can Be Sponsored for Army Recruitment Under UHQ QuotaNew Policy Update from Directorate General of Recruiting – July
- CSD Updates 2025: Enhanced Benefits for Armed Forces Personnel and FamiliesThe Directorate of Canteen Services (CSD) under the Quartermaster General’s
- Decade-long Battle for Legitimate Pay Fixation for Re-employed Ex-ServicemenSince 1986, re-employed ex-servicemen from the Commissioned Officer category have
- न्याय से वंचित? सिविल सेवाओं में PBOR पूर्व सैनिकों का PAY FIXATION संघर्ष🎤 होस्ट (प्रश्न 1):नमस्कार श्रोताओं! आज हम एक ऐसे मुद्दे
- DSC Recruitment Rally 2025 : Apply NowSecuring a government job after retiring from the Indian Armed
- Defence Quota MBBS Admission : Application Process Announced for 2025Ministry of Defence, Department of Ex-Servicemen Welfare , Kendriya Sainik