#esminfoclub |inglish Explainer
Indian Army ka naam aate hi dimaag me ek hi image aati hai — discipline, sacrifice aur desh ke liye jaan dene ka jazba. Lekin haal hi me Parliament me ek aisa mudda uthaya gaya jisne sabko sochne par majboor kar diya: सेवादारी प्रथा (Sahayak/Buddy System ka misuse).
Is issue par Parliament me kaafi teekhi behas hui, jahan allegations lage ki kuch jagahon par jawano se domestic kaam karvaye ja rahe hain — jaise jhaadu-poncha, jute polish, kapde dhona, gardening, hatta ki dogs ghumaana. Yeh mudda sirf ek practice ka nahi, balki izzat aur dignity of soldiers ka hai.
🔴 Mudda utha Parliament me – kya kaha MPs ne?
Rajya Sabha me MP Sanjay Singh ne is mudde ko uthate hue kaha:
“Jawan desh ki raksha ke liye hota hai, kisi officer ke ghar ka kaam karne ke liye nahi.”
Unhone ek example diya ek jawan ka (Harendra Yadav), jiska kehna tha ki:
- Wo Army me bandook uthane ke liye aaya tha
- Lekin usse tray uthwane, ghar ke kaam karwane ja rahe hain
Is statement ne Parliament me ek emotional aur serious debate shuru kar di.
⚠️ Sevadari Pratha kya hai?
Traditionally Army me ek Buddy System / Sahayak System hota hai jahan ek jawan officer ki field duty me help karta hai:
- Equipment handle karna
- Field movement me support
- Emergency situations me sahayata
👉 Lekin problem tab hoti hai jab iska misuse hota hai, aur jawan se:
- Personal servant jaisa kaam liya jata hai
- Domestic chores karvaye jate hain
- Non-military tasks assign kiye jate hain
📊 Parliamentary Committee bhi de chuki hai warning
Parliamentary Standing Committee ne bhi pehle recommend kiya tha ki:
- Peace stations (jahan war situation nahi hoti) me Buddy System ki zarurat nahi hai
- Is system ka misuse rokna chahiye
- Isse abolish ya reform karna chahiye
Phir bhi ground level par implementation weak dikh raha hai.
🎯 Core Issue: Respect vs Tradition
Yeh debate sirf ek system ko lekar nahi hai, balki 3 bade sawaalon ko uthata hai:
1. Kya yeh colonial legacy hai?
British time se aaya hua “batman system” aaj bhi kahin na kahin exist karta hai.
PM Narendra Modi ne khud kaha hai ki:
“Gulami ke nishaan mitane honge”
Toh sawal uthta hai:
👉 Kya Army ke andar bhi aise systems ko revisit karne ki zarurat hai?
2. Kya jawano ki dignity compromise ho rahi hai?
Ek soldier:
- Extreme conditions (Siachen, borders) me duty karta hai
- Life risk me dalta hai
Agar wahi soldier ko domestic kaam diya jaye, toh:
- Morale impact hota hai
- Respect ka issue uthta hai
3. Kya system reform possible hai?
Experts ka kehna hai:
- Field areas me limited buddy support logical hai
- Lekin peace postings me iska misuse rokna zaruri hai
🧠 Ex-Servicemen aur Experts ka kya kehna hai?
Retired officers aur defence analysts ka mixed view hai:
- Kuch log kehte hain system operational necessity hai
- Dusre kehte hain iska strict regulation ya complete abolition hona chahiye
Ek retired Colonel ne kaha:
“Jawan ko combat ke liye train kiya jata hai, servant banane ke liye nahi.”
🔥 Ground Reality vs Official Policy
Officially:
- Army ne kabhi bhi domestic servitude ko approve nahi kiya
Lekin reports aur testimonies suggest karte hain:
- Kuch units me informal practices chal rahi hain
- Accountability mechanism weak hai
🛑 Kya hone chahiye reforms?
Agar genuinely reform lana hai, toh ye steps important ho sakte hain:
- ✔️ Clear SOP: kya allowed hai aur kya nahi
- ✔️ Complaint mechanism for jawans (anonymous bhi ho)
- ✔️ Strict punishment for misuse
- ✔️ Awareness training for officers
- ✔️ Peace stations me system ka review
📝 Final Thought
Indian Army hamare desh ka garv hai. Har jawan ki respect aur dignity maintain karna utna hi zaruri hai jitna border security.
👉 “Jawan haath me rifle ke liye bana hai, jhaadu ke liye nahi” — yeh sirf ek slogan nahi, balki ek policy direction hona chahiye.
💬 Aapka kya maanna hai?
- Kya Sevadari Pratha completely band honi chahiye?
- Ya phir isme reforms laakar ise continue karna chahiye?
Apni rai doston ke sath niche diye gaye sicial media button ke saath zaroor share karein — kyunki yeh mudda har Indian ke liye important hai.
Jai Hind 🇮🇳